300 Pices of Human Flesh

The surprising verdict in the sensational Neeraj Grover Case, that has shaken the conscience of the conscientious citizens, is shockingly inadequate and can be justifiably called a case of miscarriage of justice. But, it is futile to blame the learned judge for this. Conversely, the Police in first place seem to have failed to professionally investigate and book the accused, sealing the legal loop-holes for a seasoned Criminal lawyer. Secondly, the prosecution too miserably failed to prove the charges against the accused making the assessment and conclusions of the judge truly onerous. The sincere and honest Additional Sessions Judge M W Chandwani, who presided over trial proceedings, cannot be blamed in not delivering a judgement meeting the expectations of the parties interested in the sensational case. A judge cannot decide on the quantum of punishment merely on the basis of the alleged-but-not-proved cruelty and sensational newspaper reports and the concocted story of the police alone. He is enjoined to follow the justice, equity and good conscience and be guided by proof beyond doubt in criminal case. The bereaved family and the friends of Neeraj have reasons to be rightfully agitated over the “light” punishment the accused have got away with. People are more agitated that the prima donna of the case – Kannada actress Maria Susairaj- got away so simply with a mere three years of imprisonment for causing to disappear the evidence under section 201 of the IPC, even as the prime accused navy officer Emile Jerome Mathew, was sentenced to 10 years rigorous imprisonment. Mumbai Police, known for its rare talent and investigative intelligence must introspect on the entire case and learn to tie up all the loose ends in such sensational case with more care. This case is likely to be remembered for the shoddy job done by all concerned, if the Police version of chopping Grover’s dead-body into 300 pieces is to be believed.